• No nylon
  • No glue
  • Free post in Australia
  • 30 days to try it
  • Packed by hand in South Australia
  • Horse hair + bamboo
Shop · from $12.99

Are charcoal toothbrushes worth it?

The short answer

Are charcoal toothbrushes worth it? For the look, perhaps. Charcoal on the label tells you very little about the brush: one 2020 laboratory study tested charcoal-with-nylon bristles and found no particular antimicrobial effect among the five bristle types it compared. What matters is what the bristles are actually made of, so check that before you pay extra for black.

Written by Reuben S., who runs BARE and packs every order. Published 18 August 2026 · Updated 10 November 2026

The brush we sell, the BARE toothbrush, has horse hair bristles woven into a bamboo head, with no nylon and no glue.

A bamboo-handled toothbrush with white bristles resting beside a sink.

Read the bristle line, not the colour

Charcoal is a popular word on bamboo brushes, but it describes a colour, not a complete material. The 2020 toothbrush-microbiome study included a brush it called charcoal with nylon, which is a checkable example of a black bristle that is still a plastic. It does not mean every charcoal brush is nylon, so ask the seller what the bristles are. If the answer is vague, that is worth noticing. Our guide to whether bamboo toothbrush bristles are plastic covers the wider question.

What the lab study found

The researchers tested five bristle types: nylon, pig bristles, bamboo viscose, bio-nylon, and charcoal with nylon. Charcoal and bamboo bristles are often said to be antimicrobial. In their contamination experiment, none of the types showed a particular antimicrobial effect, and bristle type made no significant difference to how bacteria grew and survived.

Keep that in proportion. It was a laboratory test of the brushes it chose, and it did not test BARE. It is a useful reason to be sceptical of the marketing, not a verdict on every charcoal product.

Do charcoal toothbrushes work?

It depends on what you expect the charcoal to do. For the antimicrobial claim, the study above is the evidence we could read, and it found no particular effect from the charcoal-with-nylon bristle it tested. It tested nothing else that charcoal is said to do. The brushing itself is done by the bristles, whatever their colour, which is why the bristle material and how soft it is matter more than the word on the box.

Are charcoal toothbrushes safe?

We can’t tell you, and that study can’t either: it measured bacteria on bristles, not teeth, gums or enamel. Whitening and safety claims are a different question, and we make none. If you are thinking about charcoal for whitening, or you have sensitive teeth or worn enamel, ask your dentist what suits your mouth.

What to check instead

The things that make a brush work are not on the colour chart. Look for soft bristles and a bristle material you have chosen knowingly: nylon (vegan, plastic) or natural hair (plastic-free, not vegan). The American Dental Association recommends rinsing thoroughly after each use and standing the brush upright to air dry. Our care guide has the details.

If a black brush suits your bathroom, buy it for that and enjoy it.

Where BARE fits

Ours is horse hair woven into a bamboo handle, with no nylon. It is an animal product, so it is not vegan. It is A$12.99 for one, with free shipping anywhere in Australia.

The short version

  • Charcoal is a label, not a bristle specification. A charcoal bristle can still be nylon.
  • One lab study found no particular antimicrobial effect from charcoal-with-nylon bristles among the types it tested.
  • Check the bristle material, not the colour.
  • Like the look? That is a fine reason to buy one.

Common questions

01Are charcoal toothbrushes worth it?

Worth it for the look, if you like it. As a reason to buy, charcoal tells you very little, because it is not a complete description of the bristle. Check what the bristles are actually made of, and look for soft bristles.

02Do charcoal toothbrushes work?

It depends on what you expect the charcoal to do. For the antimicrobial claim, the one laboratory study we could read tested a charcoal-with-nylon bristle among five types and found no particular antimicrobial effect. It tested nothing else that charcoal is said to do, and we make no claim about it. The brushing itself is done by the bristles, whatever their colour.

03Are charcoal toothbrushes safe?

We can't tell you, and the study on this page can't either: it measured bacteria on bristles, not teeth, gums or enamel. If you have sensitive teeth or worn enamel, ask your dentist what suits your mouth.

04Are charcoal toothbrush bristles still nylon?

They can be. One 2020 laboratory study tested a brush it described as charcoal with nylon, so a black bristle does not mean the plastic is gone. The label does not settle it, so ask the seller what the bristle is made of.

05Are charcoal bristles antibacterial?

In a 2020 laboratory study of five bristle types, including charcoal with nylon and bamboo viscose, none showed a particular antimicrobial effect, and bristle type made no significant difference to bacterial growth. It was a laboratory test, so it is not the last word on every product, but it is not a reason to pay extra either.

06How do I look after a charcoal toothbrush?

The same as any toothbrush. The American Dental Association recommends rinsing it thoroughly after each use and standing it upright to air dry.

Sources (2)

  1. The Toothbrush Microbiome: Impact of User Age, Period of Use and Bristle Material on the Microbial Communities of Toothbrushes. Microorganisms, 2020. DOI 10.3390/microorganisms8091379. Checked .
  2. Toothbrushes. American Dental Association. Checked .

Nothing here is dental advice. For anything about your own teeth or gums, ask your dentist or oral health therapist.