Three kinds of toothbrush, judged the same way
If you want a brush with no plastic in it, the bristles decide it: a bamboo handle with nylon bristles still has plastic in the head, and horse hair bristles don’t. If you need a vegan brush, or one you can pick up with the shopping, a plastic brush or a bamboo brush with nylon bristles will suit you better than ours.
A comparison is only fair if every brush answers the same questions. This page asks the same seven things of each brush, in the same order. Where we don’t have a sourced answer, the cell says so instead of guessing.
| Criterion | Standard plastic brush | Bamboo brush with nylon bristles | Bamboo with horse hair bristles (ours) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bristle material | Nylon, the most widely used bristle material | Nylon, the most common choice for bamboo brushes | Horse hair, woven into the head with no glue |
| Handle material | Plastic | Bamboo | Bamboo |
| Plastic content | Handle and bristles | The bristles: nylon is a plastic | None. One small aluminium staple holds the weave, and it doesn't break down |
| End of life | General waste in most areas (check your council). Most toothbrushes can't go in the home recycling bin | Pull or break off the nylon first; it goes in general waste. Some councils take the bare handle in organics or home compost | Home compost as it is. The staple doesn't break down: leave it in the home compost, or pick it out later. We haven't timed how long it takes. Check your council's rules before it goes in an organics bin |
| Price per brush | Varies by brand and shop; not priced here | Varies by brand and shop; not priced here | $12.99 single, $11.25 each in the four-pack, $10.00 each in the eight-pack |
| Replacement interval | Every 3 months, the Australian Dental Association's advice | Every 3 months, the same advice | The same advice applies. We haven't tested how long ours lasts, so we don't publish a figure |
| Who it suits | You want a brush from the supermarket, or you need a vegan brush | You want a bamboo handle and are happy with nylon bristles, or you need a vegan brush | You want no nylon in the head and you're fine with an animal fibre |
What each row measures
Each criterion is something you can check yourself. The facts about other brushes come from Australian councils, the Australian Dental Association, published research and trade sources, listed under Sources. The facts about ours are what the brush is made of. Prices for other brushes change by brand, shop and week, so rather than pick a number and call it typical, we left it out. Ours are the one-time prices; what a subscription takes off them is set out on our offers page.
- Bristle material
- What the tufts in the head are made of.
- Handle material
- What you hold.
- Plastic content
- Which parts of the brush itself are plastic. Packaging is not counted.
- End of life
- What Australian guidance says to do with the old brush.
- Price per brush
- Australian dollars, before any subscription discount. Shipping within Australia is free on ours.
- Replacement interval
- How often to swap to a new brush.
- Who it suits
- The buyer each one makes sense for.
Who shouldn’t switch to ours
Plenty of people are better off staying where they are. Rule it out quickly if any of these matters to you.
- You need a vegan brush. The bristles are horse hair, which is an animal product. Most vegan brushes use nylon bristles, and nylon is a plastic.
- You want a brush that’s made here. The business is Australian owned and designed, and every order is packed and posted by hand from South Australia, but the brush is imported.
- You want a brush with no metal at all. One small aluminium staple holds the weave, and it doesn’t break down.
- You’re allergic to horses. Read the horse allergy guide before you buy anything with horse hair in it.
- You’re happy with the nylon brush you have and plastic in the head doesn’t bother you. That’s a fair place to land, and the table won’t change it.
What most “eco” brushes actually use
The middle column is the one people get caught out by. When we read 92 eco toothbrush listings on Australian retailer sites in October 2026, 46 of the 47listings that named a bristle material described plastic bristles. That counts listings, not products or the whole market, and it’s set out in full in our audit of how retailers describe eco toothbrush bristles. A bamboo handle is a real change. It just isn’t the whole brush.
The head-to-head comparisons
Each pair gets its own page, because each one turns on a different question. These go deeper than the table can.
- Bamboo vs plastic toothbrush
Handle against handle, including what a 2020 life-cycle study found and what happens to each in the bin.
- Bamboo with nylon bristles vs no nylon at all
Why a bamboo handle on its own doesn't make a brush plastic-free, and what changes when the bristles aren't nylon either.
- Horse hair vs boar bristle
The two animal-fibre bristles side by side: where each comes from, how they're fixed in the head, and what the research covers.
- Natural bristles vs nylon
What nylon brought to the toothbrush in 1938, what natural fibres do differently, and the points where nylon genuinely wins.
Whichever you pick, replace it on time
The replacement row is identical across the table on purpose. The interval comes from dental guidance, not from the material, so a bamboo brush doesn’t earn a longer life by being bamboo. If you’d like the reasoning, read how often to replace your toothbrush, and for what happens after that, how to dispose of a bamboo toothbrush in Australia. To see how many brushes your household goes through, and the plastic in them, work it out with the household plastic calculator.
Sources
- Physicochemical Properties of Curen Filaments Versus Nylon Filaments in Toothbrush Bristles: An In Vitro Study. Cureus, 2024. DOI 10.7759/cureus.75767. Checked .
- Exploring Sustainable Alternatives for Toothbrushes. Plastics Engineering (Society of Plastics Engineers), 2024. Checked .
- Sustainable oral health care. Australian Dental Association. Checked .
- Toothbrushes and dental products (Recyclopaedia). ACT Government, City Services. Checked .
- Toothbrush (bamboo): A to Z of waste disposal guide. Maroondah City Council. Checked .
- Toothbrush. City of Onkaparinga. Checked .
- Brushing teeth. Australian Dental Association (teeth.org.au). Checked .