• No nylon
  • No glue
  • Free post in Australia
  • 30 days to try it
  • Packed by hand in South Australia
  • Horse hair + bamboo
Shop · from $12.99

Bamboo vs plastic toothbrush: an honest comparison

The short answer

Bamboo vs plastic toothbrush: which is better? A 2020 life-cycle assessment put a bamboo manual brush and a plastic manual brush with replaceable heads equal-lowest for environmental impact, both ahead of a traditional plastic brush, with electric a long way last. We sell a bamboo brush, so plainly: a refillable plastic handle scored as well as ours. Bamboo’s advantage is what happens to the handle at the end.

Written by Reuben S., who runs BARE and packs every order. Published 11 August 2026 · Updated 12 November 2026

The brush we sell, the BARE plastic-free toothbrush, has horse hair bristles woven into a bamboo head, with no nylon and no glue.

Comparison of five toothbrush types by handle material, bristle material, what is discarded, whether the head is plastic-free, what is required before composting, what happens if it is binned, and life-cycle assessment ranking.
Plastic manualPlastic, replaceable headElectricBamboo, nylon bristlesBamboo, natural bristles (ours)
HandlePlasticPlasticPlastic, with batteryBambooBamboo
BristlesNylonNylonNylonNylonHorse hair
What you throw awayWhole brushHead onlyHead only, plus the body eventuallyWhole brushWhole brush
Is the head plastic-free?NoNoNoNoYes
Before compostingNot compostableNot compostableNot compostableRemove bristles with pliersNothing to remove first; the staple doesn't break down (no finished-brush compost test)
If you just bin itLandfill, wholeLandfill, wholeLandfill; body is e-wasteLandfill, wholeLandfill, with natural fibres
LCA ranking (see below)MiddleLowest impactHighest impact: worst in 15 of 16 categoriesLowest impactNot studied

LCA ranking from “Combining evidence-based healthcare with environmental sustainability: using the toothbrush as a model”, British Dental Journal, 2020. Natural-bristle brushes were not among the four types studied.

Is a bamboo toothbrush better than a plastic one?

For the handle, yes on one count: bamboo is a plant material that breaks down, where a plastic handle does not. For the head, usually not, because the bristles on most bamboo brushes are nylon, the same plastic a plastic brush uses. On measured footprint it is a draw with the right kind of plastic brush: the one published life-cycle assessment put bamboo level with a plastic manual brush that has replaceable heads, and both ahead of a traditional plastic brush. The detail is below.

What the life-cycle assessment actually found

There is one widely cited piece of quantitative evidence here, published in the British Dental Journal in 2020. It compared four toothbrush types (a traditional plastic manual, an electric, a plastic manual with replaceable heads, and a bamboo manual) using life-cycle assessment over five years, counting raw materials, manufacture, transport, use and disposal.

Three findings, quoted rather than paraphrased:

  • The electric toothbrush “had the greatest impact in 15 out of 16 environmental categories”.
  • “The bamboo and replaceable-head plastic toothbrushes had the lowest impact in all categories.”
  • “The climate change potential of the electric toothbrush was 11 times greater than the bamboo toothbrush.”

The middle finding is the one worth sitting with, because it doesn’t suit us. A plastic brush with replaceable heads did as well as bamboo. If your priority is the measured environmental footprint rather than plastic specifically, keeping one handle and replacing only the head is as good a strategy as changing what the handle is made of.

Two caveats, in fairness to bamboo. The study covered four types and natural-bristle brushes weren’t among them, so there is no comparable figure for what we make. And an LCA measures things like carbon and water; it does not directly capture “this object still exists in two hundred years”, which is most of why people care about plastic in the first place.

Electric brushes

Electric is the clear loser environmentally, and it’s not close. An electric brush has a motor, a rechargeable battery, a charger and a circuit board, and at end of life the body is e-waste rather than general waste.

The waste unit is also different in a way people miss: you replace the head every few months, so an electric brush produces a steady stream of small plastic heads for as long as you own it.

That is a statement about environmental impact, not about your teeth. If a dentist has recommended an electric brush for you, that advice outranks anything on this page. We weigh both sides, and what to do with an old one, in are electric toothbrushes bad for the environment?

What we’re not putting in the table

Cost per year. We’d have to keep a price table current across brands we don’t control, and a stale price table is worse than none. Ours is exact and you can check it: a four-pack is $44.99, which buys four brushes. How long each one lasts depends on you, so we leave the cost per year to your own sums.

Weight of plastic avoided. We looked at publishing this and couldn’t do it honestly. We haven’t weighed the bristle tufts separately from the handles, so any figure would be a guess dressed as data. Our waste evidence and scenarios page shows what is and isn’t known. The British Dental Journal researchers also modelled a hypothetical recycled-plastic brush, which we cover in are recycled plastic toothbrushes better?

So which should you buy?

Honestly, the biggest variable isn’t in this table. Using a brush for its full life and replacing it when the bristles splay matters more than which of these you picked.

After that, in rough order:

  • If you want the lowest measured footprint: bamboo manual, or a plastic handle with replaceable heads. The evidence puts them level.
  • If you specifically want less plastic: bamboo beats a refillable plastic handle, because the handle stops being plastic. But the bristles are still nylon unless the brush says otherwise.
  • If you want no plastic in the head at all: that means natural bristle, which is what we make. It isn’t vegan.
  • If you have an electric and it suits you: keep the body for as long as it lasts. Replacing a working electric brush to save the planet is not a saving.

Common questions

01Is a bamboo toothbrush better than a plastic one?

For the handle, yes, bamboo is renewable and breaks down where plastic does not. For the head, usually not, because the bristles on most bamboo brushes are nylon. A life-cycle assessment published in the British Dental Journal in 2020 found bamboo manual brushes among the lowest impact of the four types it studied, but it found a plastic manual brush with replaceable heads performed equally well.

02Are electric toothbrushes bad for the environment?

They carry the highest environmental cost of the common options. The same 2020 life-cycle assessment found the electric toothbrush had the greatest impact in 15 of 16 environmental categories, with climate-change potential around 11 times that of a bamboo brush. That reflects the motor, battery and charger as well as the replacement heads.

03What is the most environmentally friendly toothbrush?

On the published life-cycle evidence, a bamboo manual brush and a plastic manual brush with replaceable heads came out equal-lowest, and both beat a traditional plastic brush and an electric one. That study did not include natural-bristle brushes, so no comparable figure exists for them. The larger factor in every case is that you keep the brush for its full life and replace it when the bristles splay, rather than which one you bought.

04Do bamboo and plastic toothbrushes clean differently?

The handle never touches your teeth. The bristles do, so the bristle material and its condition are what to look at, not the handle.

Sources (2)

  1. Exploring Sustainable Alternatives for Toothbrushes. Plastics Engineering (Society of Plastics Engineers), 2024. Checked .
  2. Combining evidence-based healthcare with environmental sustainability: using the toothbrush as a model. British Dental Journal, 2020. DOI 10.1038/s41415-020-1981-0. Checked .

Categories are compared as materials, not as brands. Individual products vary. Check the specific brush. Nothing here is dental advice.